Unveiling Misconceptions: Losing Weight, Protein Shakes/Bars, & “Healthy” Salads

The formula to lose weight is simple – consume less and burn more than you’re taking in. The problem is, we are impatient and get discouraged easily because we don’t see progress right away and give up. We make a few minor changes and expect to see drastic changes quickly. Sorry, that’s not how it works.

I commonly hear from friends and strangers, or from overheard conversations around campus that, “I’m eating healthy and working out, but I’m not loosing any weight – and I’ve been drinking protein!”

My first thought is, define healthy.

“Well I’m eating salads, lots of protein- like whey protein and eating protein bars, and drinking smoothies and stuff.”

Let’s break this down.

Protein drinks and protein bars are not magical products that are going to instantly make you lose a bunch of weight (like those It Works! Wrap). The macros (calories, sugars, protein, etc.) in protein shakes/bars (and smoothies) vary greatly by the type and brand. Some have really poor macros, with really high calories and unnecessary sugar. Compare products, because at the end of the day, loosing weight is all about being in a deficit with your calories. So if you aren’t mindful about your total macros for the day, and have a protein shake/bar, or anything without checking the label, you may be eating an excess of calories which will actually set you back from your weight loss goals. What you don’t use, your body will store as fat; It doesn’t care if it’s a protein bar or a donut – excess calories are excess calories.

A great tool to monitor all of your macros is MyFitnessPal. Put in your age, height, weight, etc., and choose your goal weight and a reasonable amount of time to get there.

As for salads, what are you putting in your “salad”? Is it iceberg lettuce, cheese, bacon bits, a bunch of croutons, maybe some cold pasta, followed by drenching it in ranch dressing, because that’s what makes it taste good to you? Because if so, you might as well not even bother with having a “salad”. Putting all of those things in an unreasonable proportion is defeating the purpose of actually having a salad.

Screen Shot 2016-03-27 at 10.44.25 PM.png
How to not make a salad. Ironically, 4-5 years ago, this to me was the perfect salad. I used to hate vegetables, except for a select few. Now, I love them. 🙂

Iceberg lettuce has little nutrients and is made up primarily of water. That’s why darker greens, like spinach are better for you, because they’re rich in nutrients. Yes, they have a stronger, somewhat bitter taste, but like anything, you’ll eventually get used to it and (hopefully) start to enjoy it.

Alternative example: Spinach, grilled chicken, garbanzo beans, onions, green peppers, no croutons, little or no cheese, broccoli, and a little bit of oil and red wine vinegar as a dressing.

FullSizeRender 7

The second question is, how long have you been eating differently, and what is your mentality like with exercise. Do you just go to the gym to check it off your list like a chore? Or, do you go into the gym, with the mindset of, “I’m going to challenge myself and work purposefully, focusing on each exercise, with each rep to make it count.”

Many girls go into the gym and only do the treadmill or elliptical because it’s less intimidating and if they were to pick up a weight and lift it, they’re going to all of a sudden get big and bust out with manly muscles. Or, they go into the gym in hopes of making their butt firmer, rounder, bigger, or all of the above, so they do only body weight squats and butt kicks. These exercises are great to start- to get the movement and contraction down, but if you really want to develop a better bum, honey, you’re gonna have to put some weight on that thang and challenge the glute and hamstring muscles if you want it to grow/ tighten/round! That’s why squats, lunges, deadlifts, and hip thrusters are such great exercises. They’re compound movements that target several muscles at once.

And don’t just do exercises aimlessly without thinking about what you’re doing. You see people doing this in the gym all the time and they wonder why they aren’t seeing much progress. Slow down, focus on what you’re doing with purpose; on the muscle(s) you’re using to push/pull the weight, and make it count!

Another factor that may be holding you back from loosing weight is alcohol. This is especially applicable towards college students. You can’t be drinking heavily every single weekend and expect to loose weight. A beer has typically 150 calories give or take. Say you have 3 in one night – that’s almost 500 calories. Have drinks in moderation, and if you know you’re going to have a couple drinks later that night, work with more intensity in the gym, and do extra cardio.

Join me on IG and Twitter @hmillerfit


10 thoughts on “Unveiling Misconceptions: Losing Weight, Protein Shakes/Bars, & “Healthy” Salads

  1. This was an awesome post! Loved reading it! Its so true though how people think protein shakes and bars are the miracle to losing weight. I used to eat salads just like the first picture and totally thought that was healthy, that is until I put on around 10 lbs and figured out healthy meant fruits, veggies lean meats and less calories!


  2. I know! I used to eat salads like that and think that protein shakes/bars were the secret to loosing weight too. So naive. And some companies are to blame too for how they advertise their products – deceptive to those who’re new to trying to live a healthier lifestyle.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I might add that there are other issues with the struggles of weight loss. There’s a definite genetic predisposition. When I was younger, I barely had to do anything to lose weight. The same with my Dad and one of my sons. I’d just slightly increase my activity level, and weight would drip off.

    Now, as I’ve gotten older (I blame Mom’s genes for this since my Dad still has no problem with losing weight), it’s a greater struggle. Yes, I can do it with a lot of disciple and counting, counting, counting of calories, but no two people have exactly the same experience with their bodies.

    The trick is to get to know your body, what works, and what doesn’t, and make a plan based on reasonable cardio, resistance training, and diet (what you eat, when you eat, and portion control), and then work the plan.


    1. True, age and genetics play a large role as well. I have a lot of respect for how dedicated you are with fitness and your blog. I love the layout by the way, it looks great. 🙂

      I agree with you that it’s super important to get to know your body and how it responds to different exercises (and how they’re performed) and different foods and ratios of macros.

      Thanks for your input James. 🙂


  4. This is exactly why I’m fat. I am not the kind of person who needs dressing but my body struggles to lose weight if I eat carbs from any source other than vegetables. Sugar gives me gas so I try not to eat that either. I notice when I eat low carb I lose weight just fine but I worry I’m not getting enough nutrients. Nice post!


    1. Kyanna,

      Thank you for stopping by and commenting. 🙂

      It may seem tedious, to track everything you eat, but you should really try MyFitnessPal. It will show you what percentage of carbs, protein, fats, and how many calories you should aim for. You can even scan labels or search foods to add into your “food diary”, which makes it easy. If you were to do this for a month, I believe you would see a difference and feel better- especially if you try to eat more whole foods, fresh produce and stuff- you will give your body more nutrients.

      If you ever have a question about anything, feel free to email me. My address is under “Contact” at the top. 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to emulcahy33 Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s